Pomodoro Pizzeria

Legit NY pizza. Better than some I've had in both NYC and Italy. Many places in delmarva say they have NY pizza but this is the only one that deserves that title that I have found. They are right in the busy area of Bethany with no parking and as much as we hate going there it's worth it for this place. It's small and family run. The only downside is you better call early for carry out (I'm talking in the afternoon for an evening pick up) because they don't sacrifice quality for quantity.

- Kris -

Manhattan resident perspective: pizza here is by FAR the best in the area. Please do not go to Grottos or other shops in the area. Pomodoro makes some of the best pizza outside of any city by far. It’s always refreshing to get that crunchy crust and they execute on that here very well. The main difference between NYC pizza and Pomodoro is NYC pizza has a very tomato flavor profile. Pomodoro has a big cheese flavor profile. I think both are great! Will 100% come back to Pomodoro and I recommend to all! 1.50 for a slice is a steal! $22 for a pizza is slightly pricey but definitely worth it.

- Patrick -

all take away - perfect place for NY style! check hours before going. Closed till Spring 2026

- LB B (LBB) -

Even though we were absolutely stuffed from eating burgers for lunch, we couldn’t resist when we saw a sign for “NY-style pizza.” We decided to go in and take “one bite” just to give it a Dave Portnoy rating. We ordered a single slice of Margherita to share among the three of us. After just one bite, we all looked at each other and said this was the best NY-style pizza we’ve ever had. It was that good. Of course, we went right back in and ordered a whole pie and the rest was history. The sweet lady who owns the place told us she was from Italy and I told her many many times over that her pizza was the best NY style pizza. She definitely makes her pizza with love!

- Jae Choi -

Great pizza and wonderful people! I needed 10 pizzas on a busy Saturday night and they had them ready in less than 30 minutes. I had to double park and they kindly brought all the pizzas to my car. The Caesar salad was fresh romaine and a good dressing- will definitely order here again when at Bethany Beach!

- Vakelleys -

I just moved to Bethany a few years ago From New Jersey. I’ve been coming here since the spring and The owners are some of the nicest and most caring people ever. Always friendly, always on time and the pizza is the closest you Will find in Sussex county that tastes like NY/NJ pizza. Thank you for bringing great pizza to the area!

- Kelly D -

Amazing NYC pizza! The crust was perfectly thin, great sauce, everything had a great flavor. I loved how snappy and lovely the owner was. She got us our pizza very quickly and was clear about how long it would take (10 minutes). We got mushroom, pepperoni, & a spinach, ricotta, tomato something. Everything was delicious & filled us up. We were very happy about it.

- McKayla Doty -

Pizza take-out only - whole pie and slices. I like that they had a selection of slices available with different toppings and generous size slices. We ordered 3 slices and on the first bite it was crisp and very flavorful. Cooked perfectly. The cheese they use is high quality. I will definitely be returning hopefully before they close for the season. Highly recommend and not too far from Delaware Seashore State Park where we are camping. Very efficient service.

- Alisa DeGeorge -